As an expert in shame and its impact on human behavior, I have been keenly aware of a lack of shame among Republican politicians, especially in the past 10 years. Donald Trump, of course, is leading the competition in his complete lack of humility and in his inability to tolerate shame, causing what could be described as extremely high levels of sociopathic or narcissistic traits. The other emotion and behavior that I’d like to discuss here is humility, an associated moral or prosocial trait that spins out of healthy shame tolerance.
The new Trump administration gives us numerous examples of lack of humility. The obvious recent example, among very many among the MAGAt crowd, is the scandal of texting war plans over Signal. Trump has gathered so many shameless, hubristic idiots around him that all of these nine high-level administration cabinet members and intelligence officers agreed to share top-secret war plans on an unsecured messaging app. Not one of them spoke up and said this was inappropriate.
Of course, Trump’s endless fire hose of Executive Orders and violations of the Constitution and rule of law are clear signs of lack of humility. He views himself as above the law and as king, a grandiosity that is jaw-dropping especially given his utter lack of competence.
His nominations of a slew of incompetent individuals to powerful Cabinet posts and their acceptance of these posts shows the depth and breadth of the lack of humility in Trump’s orbit. The very fact that there are so many blatantly unqualified people in Trump’s cabinet is proof of the lack of humility rampant in the MAGA administration. If they had any humility they would turn down a nomination they were unqualified to handle. Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth has never run any organization of any size and failed at the two small non-profits he did administer and yet now is head of the largest and most powerful government department in the world. Tulsi Gabbard has never worked in the intelligence service, a standard requirement for Director of National Intelligence, and she appears to be cozy with dictators. Secretary of Education Linda McMahon is best known for promoting professional wrestling and has never worked as an educator. Of course, Trump, the head of this motley crew, was first elected president having never served in elected office, never served in the military (in fact begged for five deferments during the Vietnam era), had no public policy education or experience, was charged with running a fraudulent charity and “university,” and was a failed businessman with six bankruptcies. Millions of Americans were more qualified to be president than he was, if nothing else on grounds of good character.
In 2018 I wrote about the fact that three convicted criminals were running in the Republican party, and things have not improved since then, as voters elected Trump a 34-time convicted felon to the highest office in the land.
Even in the GOP slogans of “Make America Great Again” and Trump’s claims that only he can save us are completely lacking in humility. His recent speech to the joint session of Congress was a recitation of his campaign boasting and false claims of superiority, unlike speeches of past new presidents who usually attempt to build a bigger tent by stating they represent all Americans even those who didn’t vote for them.
Shamelessness, Narcissism, Hubris, and A Humility Deficit
As I have written extensively, it is the lack of a healthy ability to tolerate shame that causes narcissism and other antisocial psychological behaviors and personalities.
One resulting behavior is a lack humility, which appears to be epidemic in MAGA world. Many Other-Blamers, as I label these people, exhibit grandiosity, lack of self-awareness of their limits, entitlement, unrealistic risk taking, vanity, and a belief they are above the law. Other-Blamers are extremely averse to admitting their faults, mistakes or limitations.
In healthy humans, humility is an essential emotion and cognition that tells us when we are out of our depth. The Greeks have a word for lack of humility, which the English language lacks, so we have adopted it: hubris. It expresses the lack of self-awareness that comes from excessive self-regard.
The shamelessness and lack of humility in the MAGAt world will continue to cause chaos and illegality, because of their lack of morality and self-insight. Hubris causes an over-estimation of one’s abilities and leads to over-reach, such as taking on a government position one is completely unqualified to handle or callously using Signal to plan a bombing in Yemen. Inevitably, the result is failure and exposure of that failure and then further shame, which the person is unable to handle, creating a shame spiral. The more the person fails, the more shame they feel, and the more they compensate by narcissistic behaviors — lack of humility, boasting, grandiosity and further over-reaching.
Evolutionary psychologists tells us that shame is the emotion that should instantly arise when we do something immoral. It is considered a moral emotion because it should lead to feelings of contrition, remorse and accountability.
Humility is then the emotion that should constrain our behavior going forward. We recall with guilt the past bad behavior or failure and we feel humbled by that experience. In response, we temper our immoral actions and make better choices, such as by recognizing our limits and admitting them. Healthy humility is essential for healthy human relationships, because we should all recognize our limits, whether those are intellectual, physical or emotional.
In terms of social dynamics, we can describe this in how we interact with others in our “tribe.” Humility tells us to “down-rank” ourselves and humble ourselves in front of our tribe mates who we may have wronged. Those who lack humility — sociopaths and narcissists— tend to very briefly feel shame, but then compensate by “up-ranking” themselves using gloating, boasting, threats, and dominance.
Please, Bring Back Humility
Trumpworld very clearly lacks humility and it is obvious this is harming our American democracy, culture and social norms. Their collective inability to handle the emotion of shame means they cannot admit fault in any way. Even when caught completely red-handed making egregious mistakes, false statements and even being convicted of breaking the law multiple times.
Paul Krugman on Substack debates whether Trumpists are “incompetent or evil” and decides the answer is yes — they are both incompetent and evil. The root is that they lack emotional maturity regarding the moral emotions. They never learned to handle shame and as a result they are not humble enough to know that they are incompetent, leading them to make terrible mistakes and harm others. And they are not able to constrain their own behaviors with accountability — the normal result of healthy shame tolerance — making them evil.
The problem going forward is politically we have essentially no way to hold Trump and his cronies accountable and therefore humble them. Impeachment is off the table, because of the complete spinelessness of GOP congress members. The Supreme Court has ruled that Trump is immune from any prosecution and Trump can pardon any of his administration members who do anything illegal. And the MAGA world, because of their severe narcissism, are immune to public shaming because they lack the ability to feel shame and remorse. We cannot expect them to be humble in their responses to mistake as they have never shown this ability. They are now unrestrained by law, by their cheerleaders in the MAGA media echo chamber, and by their rabid base. Maybe someday we will as a society regain a healthy sense of humility and politicians will regain a sense of decency, but I suspect it will be a long road back.
you may also like…
Trump Has Unleashed an Epidemic of Narcissism
Antisocial Trump Harms ou Prosocial Mental Wellbeing
A Psychological Explainer on Why We Must Hold Trump Accountable
I wonder if they lack the ability to feel shame or if when they do, the denial becomes so overwhelming that it buries any feelings. And to bury those feelings, they have no choice but to think higher of themselves than they should.
I believe that shame often goes undetected by our own arrogance and refusal to accept who we are.
It’s been a while, Harper, but I’m glad to see you again.
John, great to hear your wise input. You are correct. I sometimes simplify too much by saying people “don’t feel shame,” when they do deep down, but then cope by deflecting and externalizing it. And accepting our inherent imperfections as humans does help one become healthy and shame tolerant. Hope your books on shame continue to help others!